- Negotiators say 2 proposals submitted by Tehran undo months of work at previous rounds of talks, ‘time is running out’ for diplomacy; Macron: renewal of talks could be delayed
- Israeli Mossad head says agency will ‘do everything needed to alleviate threat,’ but Air Force head won’t say if Israel can destroy Iran’s program and report claims IDF has no strike plan
European diplomats expressed “disappointment and concern” on Friday after five days of international negotiations in Vienna on reviving the 2015 Iran nuclear deal after Iran submitted two draft proposals that appeared to undo months of dialogue.
Senior diplomats from the E3 group of Britain, France and Germany expressed “disappointment and concern after thoroughly and carefully analyzing Iranian proposed changes to the text negotiated during the previous six rounds,” which took place earlier this year.
“Tehran is walking back almost all of the difficult compromises crafted after many months of hard work,” they said, adding that the Iranian delegation had demanded “major changes.”
They went on to say it was “unclear how these new gaps can be closed in a realistic timeframe.”
The latest round of talks began on Monday between the E3, Iran, China and Russia, with the United States participating indirectly.
Diplomats were aiming to revive the 2015 deal, which began unraveling in 2018 when then-US president Donald Trump pulled out of the deal and reimposed sanctions, prompting Iran to start exceeding limits on its nuclear program the following year.
The diplomats said the delegations needed to “return to capitals to assess the situation and seek instructions, before reconvening next week to see whether gaps can be closed or not.”
“Our governments remain fully committed to a diplomatic way forward. But time is running out,” they said.
Iran said on Thursday it had submitted two draft proposals for the nuclear agreement.
Iran’s chief nuclear negotiator, Ali Bagheri, arrives at the Coburg Palais in Vienna for nuclear talks, on November 29, 2021. (Vladimir Simicek/AFP)
On Thursday, Iran’s lead negotiator Ali Bagheri said the proposals concerned two main issues facing the 2015 accord known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, or JCPOA.
“The first document sums up the Islamic republic’s point of view concerning the lifting of sanctions, while the second is about Iran’s nuclear actions,” Bagheri told state television.
“Now the other side must examine these documents and prepare itself to hold negotiations with Iran based on these documents.”
Extreme and maximalist
An E3 diplomat told Israel’s Walla news that the draft on sanctions relief was extreme and maximalist, with the Iranians increasing their sanctions relief demands in comparison to agreements reached with the Rouhani government last June.
The talks had resumed in the Austrian capital on Monday after Iran paused them in June following the election of ultraconservative President Ebrahim Raisi.
The diplomat also told Walla that Iran had backtracked on the nuclear draft too, removing all the previously agreed upon compromise language on steps to roll back their nuclear program.
1 The nuclear negotiators for the E3 – France, Germany and the UK – in coordination with the U.S. told Iranian negotiators in Vienna that the opening proposals they presented in the talks this week were not serious and unacceptable, an E3 diplomat briefed on the talks said
— Barak Ravid (@BarakRavid) December 3, 2021
“The Iranians have been told their proposals are not serious and they are to go back to Tehran and get further instructions,” the diplomat said.
Iran’s semi-official ISNA news agency said the talks would “most likely” resume on Monday but French President Emmanuel Macron warned there could be a longer break in the talks, which only resumed on November 29 after a five-month break.
Speaking on a visit to the United Arab Emirates, just across the Gulf from Iran, the French president said it “should not be excluded” that this round of talks “does not reopen swiftly.”
Including the Gulf states and Israel
However, in comments likely to please his Gulf hosts but anger Iran, Macron said a broader framework might benefit the talks on bringing Washington back into the deal.
He appeared to suggest bringing the Gulf states and even Israel into the talks, although having Iranian and Israeli envoys at the same table appears almost impossible.
“I think everyone is conscious of the fact that not talking, not trying to find a new framework on both nuclear and regional issues, weakens everybody and is a factor in increasing confliction,” the French president said.
“It is also important to reengage a slightly broader dynamic and involve regional powers as well,” he added.
“It is difficult to reach an agreement if the Gulf states, Israel and all those whose security is directly affected are not involved.”
On Thursday, Prime Minister Naftali Bennett called for an “immediate cessation” of the nuclear talks, accusing Iran of “nuclear blackmail.”
In a phone call with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Bennett called instead for “concrete measures” to be taken against the Islamic republic.
The goal of the JCPOA is to make it practically impossible for Iran to build an atomic bomb, while allowing it to pursue a civilian nuclear program. Iran denies wanting a nuclear arsenal.
Blinken said Thursday it was not too late for Iran to revive its nuclear deal with world powers, but cautioned that hopes for the success of the talks were wearing thin.
“I think in the very near future, the next day or so, we’ll be in a position to judge whether Iran actually intends now to engage in good faith,” Blinken told reporters in Stockholm on the sidelines of a meeting of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe. “I have to tell you, recent moves, recent rhetoric, don’t give us a lot of cause for optimism.”
“But even though the hour is getting very late, it is not too late for Iran to reverse course,” Blinken added.
Meanwhile, the head of the Israeli Mossad spy agency said Thursday that a bad nuclear deal between world powers and Iran would be “intolerable” for Israel, vowing that the Islamic Republic will never acquire nuclear weapons.
“It’s clear that there’s no need for uranium enriched to 60 percent for civilian purposes,” David Barnea said during a ceremony at the President’s Residence to honor exceptional Mossad agents. “There’s no need for three enrichment sites. There’s no need for thousands of active centrifuges — unless, that is, there is an intention to develop nuclear weapons.”
“A bad deal, which I hope will not be made, is intolerable to us,” he added. “Iran is striving for regional hegemony, wages terrorism that we are blocking every day around the world, and is continuously threatening stability in the Middle East.”
“Our eyes are open, we are prepared, and we will do with our partners in the security establishment everything that is necessary to alleviate the threat against Israel and thwart it by any means,” Barnea said.
“Iran will not have nuclear weapons — not in the coming years, not ever. That is my promise, that is Mossad’s promise.”
